Occupational therapy or physical therapy: which one do you need?
Physical therapy restores movement. Occupational therapy restores the daily activities movement is for. How to tell which you need, when it is both, and what OT does that surprises people.
Blog · · 643 words
Physical therapy works on movement itself: strength, range, balance and pain. Occupational therapy works on the activities that movement is for: dressing, cooking, bathing, writing, getting in and out of a car. If the problem is that your shoulder will not lift, that is physical therapy. If the problem is that you cannot fasten a bra or reach the second shelf, that is occupational therapy. After a stroke or a hand injury it is routinely both.
Key facts, with sources
The fastest way to tell them apart
Ask yourself what a good outcome would sound like.
If the answer is a measurement, more degrees of shoulder movement, more strength, less pain walking, steadier on stairs, that is physical therapy. It works on the capacity.
If the answer is a task, buttoning a shirt, making a meal without needing to sit down halfway, driving again, getting back to a job that needs your hands, that is occupational therapy. It works backwards from the activity, and it will change the task and the environment as readily as it changes you.
The word occupational is misleading
Almost everyone assumes it means work. It means occupation in the older sense: the things that occupy your day. Dressing, eating, washing, cooking, managing medication, getting to the toilet at night, handling a phone.
That misunderstanding costs people. Families decline an occupational therapy referral for a retired parent because nobody is going back to work, and the referral was about whether they can safely make lunch.
Where they overlap, and why that is not duplication
After a stroke, both. After a hand or wrist injury, both, frequently with hand therapy as a specialism sitting inside occupational therapy. For an older adult who has become unsteady, physical therapy trains the balance while occupational therapy makes the bathroom survivable during the months that training takes.
They are attacking the same problem from two ends: physical therapy raises what you are capable of, occupational therapy lowers what the task demands. The gap between those two is where independence actually sits, and closing it from both sides is faster than either alone.
What occupational therapy does that people do not expect
Home assessment and modification. Not generic advice, but grab bar placement based on how you actually transfer, seat and bed heights measured against your leg length, and identifying the specific rug you trip on rather than advising you to remove rugs.
Adaptive equipment, and the training to use it, which is the part that gets skipped. A piece of equipment nobody was taught to use is a piece of equipment in a cupboard.
Energy conservation for people managing fatigue, which is a genuine clinical skill: sequencing a day so the important things happen while there is still capacity for them.
And cognitive and perceptual work after a brain injury, which is a long way from what the name suggests.
How to decide when nobody has told you
If you are unsure, an evaluation will sort it out, and both professions are obliged to refer on when something falls outside their scope.
The practical shortcut: describe the problem as a sentence about your day rather than as a body part. Saying you cannot get out of the bath produces a better referral than saying your hip hurts, because it tells whoever is listening which of the two questions you are actually asking.
Questions people ask about this
Can I have both at once?
Yes, and it is common after a stroke, a hand injury or a hospital stay. The two plans should be coordinated rather than run independently, which is easier when both come from the same practice.
Is occupational therapy about returning to work?
Sometimes, but occupation here means any daily activity. Dressing, cooking and bathing count, and for most patients those are the goals.
Can occupational therapy happen at home?
Yes, and it is usually better there, because the home is a large part of what is being assessed and adapted.
Does insurance cover occupational therapy?
Commonly, including Medicare and Medicaid, where there is a documented functional deficit. We verify your specific benefits before the first visit.
Which one should I book if I am not sure?
Call and describe the problem as something you cannot do in your day. We will tell you which evaluation fits, and it is a short conversation.
Read next
Sources
- [1] American Occupational Therapy Association, About Occupational Therapy
- [2] APTA, Physical Therapist Scope of Practice
This article is general information, not medical advice for your situation. Published evidence is described as published evidence; we make no claim about outcomes at this practice.
Talk it through with a therapist
No charge for a question. We would rather tell you physical therapy is not the answer than book you in.
Call (602) 439-3800 Request an appointment